Skip to content

Bible Study: 9th Commandment — Do Not Bear False Witness (Exo 20:16)

Question

What does the Bible say about the ninth commandment? What does "false witness" (ed shaqer / ed shav) mean -- Exodus uses shav (H7723, "vain/worthless") while Deuteronomy uses shaqer (H8267, "lying/deceitful"). Is this limited to courtroom testimony or does it cover all falsehood? Trace through Lev 19:11, Proverbs (6:16-19; 12:17,19,22), Jesus on truthfulness (Mat 5:33-37), Paul (Col 3:9), Satan as "father of lies" (John 8:44) vs. God who "cannot lie" (Titus 1:2). Examine Rahab (Jos 2; Heb 11:31; Jas 2:25) and the Hebrew midwives (Exo 1:15-21).

Discovered Scope

Topics Found (from naves_semantic.py)

Topic Score Key Verse References
TESTIMONY 0.69 1CH 16:8,9; PSA 9:11; ISA 43:10; 44:8; MAT 5:15
WITNESS 0.64 LEV 5:1; PRO 18:17; EXO 22:11; NUM 35:30; DEU 17:6; 19:15; MAT 18:16; JHN 8:17; 2CO 13:1; 1TI 5:19; HEB 10:28
FALSEHOOD 0.53/0.72 EXO 20:16; 23:1; LEV 6:2-7; 19:11,12,16; JOB 27:4; PSA 5:6; 12:2,3; 34:13; 52:2-5; 101:5,7; PRO 6:12,17-19; 12:17,19,22; 14:5,25; 19:5,9; JHN 8:44,45; EPH 4:25; COL 3:9; 1TI 1:9,10; REV 21:8,27; 22:15
INTEGRITY 0.78 GEN 18:19; EXO 18:21; PSA 15:1-5; 24:3-5; PRO 12:22; ISA 33:15,16; MIC 6:8
HONESTY 0.71 LEV 19:35,36; DEU 16:20; PRO 12:22; ISA 33:15,16; ROM 12:17; 2CO 8:21; PHP 4:8
DECEPTION 0.76 GEN 3:4; 12:13; 26:7; 27:6-24; 34; JOS 2:4-6; 9; 1SA 21; 2KI 5:20-24; 10:18-28; ACT 5:1-10
DECEIT 0.74 PSA 5:6; 119:118; PRO 12:5,17; 14:8,25; 24:28; 26:24-26; JER 17:9; ROM 3:13; MRK 7:22; COL 2:8; 1PE 2:1,22; 3:10; REV 14:5
LIARS 0.45/0.61 PSA 116:11; JHN 8:44,55; REV 21:8
PERJURY 0.60 LEV 6:2-7; 19:12; JER 5:2; 7:9; ZEC 5:4; 8:17; MAL 3:5; MAT 5:33; 1TI 1:9,10
SLANDER 0.71 PSA 15:1,3; 31:13; 34:13; 50:20; 109:3; PRO 6:19; 10:18; 11:9; 16:28; MAT 5:11; 12:36; DEU 19:16-21; REV 12:10
GOSSIP 0.71 LEV 19:16; PSA 50:20; PRO 11:13; 20:19; EZK 22:9
EVIDENCE 0.39 EXO 20:16; 23:1,7; LEV 5:1; 24:14; NUM 35:30; DEU 17:6,7; 19:15-21; PRO 24:28; MAT 18:16; HEB 10:28
TRUTH 0.51 JOS 24:14; PRO 12:17,22; 23:23; ZEC 8:16,19; EPH 4:25; 5:9; 6:14; JHN 8:44; TIT 1:1,2; NUM 23:19; PSA 31:5; 119:160
ACCUSATION, FALSE 0.48/0.50 EXO 23:1,7; LEV 19:16; PSA 41:5-9; MAT 5:11; 26:59-61; ACT 6:11,13
FALSE CONFIDENCE 0.42/0.55 DEU 29:19; PRO 3:5; ISA 5:21; ROM 12:16
SELF-DECEPTION 0.38/0.71 JAS 1:26
LYING 0.44/0.53 1KI 22:21-23; 2CH 18:20-22
DISHONESTY 0.60/0.66 LEV 6:2-7; 19:13,35,36; DEU 25:13-16; PRO 11:1; 20:10; ISA 32:7; HOS 4:1,2; MIC 6:10,11
SINCERITY 0.64 EPH 6:5-7; 1CO 10:31
FAITHFULNESS 0.56 PSA 12:1; PRO 20:6; 28:20; MAT 10:22; 1CO 4:2; REV 2:10
CONSCIENCE 0.50 ROM 2:14,15; ACT 23:1; 24:16; 1TI 1:5,19; HEB 13:18

Verse References (from Nave's entries)

Core Commandment Verses: - EXO 20:16 (the commandment itself) - DEU 5:20 (Deuteronomic restatement -- uses shav instead of sheqer) - LEV 19:11 (three linked prohibitions: steal, deal falsely, lie) - LEV 19:12 (false swearing profanes God's name) - LEV 19:16 (talebearer/gossip prohibition)

Evidence/Witness Laws: - EXO 23:1,7 (false reports, unjust causes) - LEV 5:1 (obligation to testify) - LEV 24:14 (laying hands on accused) - NUM 35:30 (two witnesses for death penalty) - DEU 17:6,7 (two or three witnesses; witnesses throw first stone) - DEU 19:15-21 (false witness penalty: lex talionis applied) - DEU 22:13-19 (false accusation of bride)

Proverbs on Truth and Lies: - PRO 6:12,13,16-19 (seven abominations -- false witness and lying tongue) - PRO 10:9,10,18,31 (integrity vs. perversity) - PRO 12:17,19,20,22 (faithful witness, lying lips, truth endures) - PRO 13:5 (righteous hateth lying) - PRO 14:5,8,25 (faithful vs. false witness) - PRO 19:5,9,22,28 (false witness shall not be unpunished) - PRO 21:6 (lying tongue = vanity) - PRO 24:28 (be not a false witness) - PRO 25:18 (false witness = war club, sword, arrow) - PRO 26:18,19,24-26,28 (deception and hatred) - PRO 27:14 (flattery)

Psalms on Truth/Falsehood: - PSA 5:6,9 (God abhors liars) - PSA 12:2,3 (flattering lips, double heart) - PSA 15:1-5 (who shall dwell in thy tabernacle -- speaks truth, no slander) - PSA 24:3-5 (clean hands, no vanity/shav, no deceit) - PSA 31:18 (lying lips silenced) - PSA 34:13 (keep thy tongue from evil) - PSA 50:19,20 (mouth to evil, tongue frameth deceit) - PSA 52:2-5 (lying tongue, loving evil more than good) - PSA 58:3 (wicked estranged from womb, speaking lies) - PSA 101:5,7 (slander, deceit shall not dwell) - PSA 116:11 (all men are liars) - PSA 119:29,69,163 (remove false way, hate lying) - PSA 120:2-4 (lying lips, deceitful tongue) - PSA 144:8,11 (right hand of falsehood)

Prophetic Denunciations: - ISA 28:15 (covenant with lies) - ISA 32:7 (instruments of the churl) - ISA 57:11 (feared not God, lied) - ISA 59:3,4,12,13 (lying, speaking oppression) - JER 7:8,28 (trust in lying words) - JER 9:3,5,6,8 (tongue bent like bow for lies; deceive neighbor) - JER 12:6 (brethren dealt treacherously) - HOS 4:1,2 (no truth in the land; swearing, lying, killing, stealing) - MIC 6:12 (tongue is deceitful) - NAM 3:1 (woe to city of lies) - ZEP 3:13 (remnant shall not speak lies) - ZEC 8:16,17 (speak truth, no false oath)

Jesus on Truthfulness: - MAT 5:33-37 (swear not at all; yea yea, nay nay) - MAT 5:11 (blessed when falsely accused) - MAT 12:36 (every idle word) - MAT 15:19 (false witness proceeds from heart) - MAT 19:18 (quoting ninth commandment) - MAT 25:44-46 (false profession) - MAT 26:59-61 (false witnesses against Jesus) - JHN 8:44,45 (devil is father of lies; no truth in him) - JHN 14:6 (I am the truth)

NT Teaching on Truth/Falsehood: - ACT 5:1-10 (Ananias and Sapphira -- lying to the Holy Spirit) - ROM 1:25 (changed truth of God into a lie) - EPH 4:25,29 (put away lying, speak truth) - COL 3:9 (lie not one to another) - 1TI 1:9,10 (law for liars and perjured persons) - 1TI 4:2 (speaking lies in hypocrisy) - TIT 1:2 (God cannot lie) - HEB 6:18 (impossible for God to lie) - 1PE 2:1,22 (lay aside guile; Christ did no guile) - 1PE 3:10 (refrain tongue from evil, lips from guile) - 1JN 1:10 (if we say we have not sinned, make him a liar) - 1JN 2:4 (he that saith I know him and keepeth not = liar) - REV 14:5 (no guile in their mouths) - REV 21:8 (all liars in lake of fire) - REV 21:27 (nothing that maketh a lie enters new Jerusalem) - REV 22:15 (without are whosoever loveth and maketh a lie)

Case Studies -- Deception Narratives: - EXO 1:15-21 (Hebrew midwives defy Pharaoh; God blesses them) - JOS 2:4-6 (Rahab hides spies, lies to king's men) - HEB 11:31 (Rahab commended by faith) - JAS 2:25 (Rahab justified by works -- receiving messengers) - GEN 3:4,5 (Satan's first lie to Eve) - GEN 12:11-19 (Abraham lies about Sarah) - GEN 20:2 (Abraham again) - GEN 26:7 (Isaac lies about Rebekah) - GEN 27:6-24 (Jacob deceives Isaac) - 1SA 19:12-17 (Michal lies to protect David) - 1SA 21 (David lies to Ahimelech) - 2SA 17:15-22 (Hushai's messengers hidden) - 1KI 21:7-13 (false witnesses against Naboth) - ACT 6:11-14 (false witnesses against Stephen)

Strong's Numbers Found (from semantic_strongs.py)

Hebrew -- Core Terms: | Strong's | Word | Relevance | |----------|------|-----------| | H7723 | shav (שָׁוְא) -- emptiness, falsehood, worthlessness | Used in Deu 5:20 for "false" witness; also in 3rd commandment (Exo 20:7) | | H8267 | sheqer (שֶׁקֶר) -- untruth, falsehood, sham | Used in Exo 20:16 for "false" witness; 113 occurrences | | H5707 | ed (עֵד) -- witness | The noun "witness" in the commandment | | H6030 | anah (עָנָה) -- to answer, testify, respond | The verb "bear witness" in the commandment | | H3576 | kazab (כָּזַב) -- to lie, deceive | Related Hebrew verb for lying | | H3577 | kazab (כָּזָב) -- falsehood, untruth | Noun form: lies, falsehood | | H3584 | kachash (כָּחַשׁ) -- to be untrue, feign, disown | Deal falsely, deny, lie | | H3585 | kachash (כַּחַשׁ) -- hypocrisy, lies, leanness | Noun: lying, lies | | H3586 | kechash (כֶּחָשׁ) -- faithless, lying | Adjective: lying | | H571 | emeth (אֶמֶת) -- stability, certainty, truth | Core OT word for truth; 127 occurrences | | H529 | emuwn (אֵמוּן) -- trusty, faithfulness, truth | Related: faithful, truth | | H391 | akzab (אַכְזָב) -- falsehood, treachery | Liar, lie | | H5715 | eduwth (עֵדוּת) -- testimony | Feminine of ed; testimony, witness |

Greek -- Core Terms: | Strong's | Word | Relevance | |----------|------|-----------| | G5576 | pseudomartureo (ψευδομαρτυρέω) -- bear false witness | NT verb for bearing false witness | | G5577 | pseudomarturia (ψευδομαρτυρία) -- false witness | NT noun for false testimony | | G5575 | pseudomartus (ψευδομάρτυρ) -- false witness (person) | Spurious witness, bearer of false testimony | | G5571 | pseudes (ψευδής) -- untrue, false, liar | Adjective: false, erroneous | | G5573 | pseudologos (ψευδολόγος) -- mendacious, speaking lies | Speaking lies | | G5579 | pseudos (ψεῦδος) -- falsehood, lie | Core Greek noun for lie/falsehood | | G5582 | pseusma (ψεῦσμα) -- fabrication, falsehood | A fabrication, lie | | G3141 | marturia (μαρτυρία) -- evidence, testimony, witness | Core Greek noun for testimony | | G3140 | martureo (μαρτυρέω) -- to witness, testify | Core Greek verb for testifying | | G4828 | summartureo (συμμαρτυρέω) -- testify jointly | Corroborate, bear witness with | | G225 | aletheia (ἀλήθεια) -- truth | Core Greek noun for truth | | G226 | aletheuo (ἀληθεύω) -- to be true, speak truth | Verb: speak/tell the truth | | G4103 | pistos (πιστός) -- faithful, trustworthy | Faithful, true, trustworthy |

Study Question Relevance
cmd-04-third-commandment-gods-name "What does 'take the name of the LORD thy God in vain' mean?" Direct overlap: Shav (H7723) links 3rd and 9th commandments; extensive analysis of shav already done; Mat 5:33-37 analyzed
cmd-09-eighth-commandment-stealing "What does the Bible say about the eighth commandment?" Adjacent commandment: Lev 19:11 links stealing, dealing falsely, lying
cmd-08-seventh-commandment-adultery "What does the Bible say about the seventh commandment?" Hos 4:1-2 lists swearing, lying alongside adultery
true-false-prophets "What is the biblical criteria for distinguishing a true prophet from a false prophet?" False prophets as a form of false witness
knowledge-accountability-judgment (no question found) God judging based on truth/knowledge

Key Findings from Related Studies: - cmd-04 (3rd Commandment) already established: (1) Shav (H7723) means "emptiness, falsehood, worthlessness" and appears in BOTH Exo 20:7 (3rd cmd) and Deu 5:20 (9th cmd); (2) The LXX translates shav with both mataios (empty) and pseudes (false); (3) Mat 5:33-37 was analyzed re: oaths; (4) Psa 24:4 combines shav with nasa -- not lifting soul to vanity; (5) E239 already registered: "The Deuteronomy version of the 9th commandment uses shav (H7723) instead of sheqer (H8267)" - cmd-09 (8th Commandment) registered E470: "Ye shall not steal, neither deal falsely, neither lie one to another" (Lev 19:11) -- three prohibitions linking theft, falsehood, and lying - cmd-evidence.db already has N036: "Shav (H7723) linguistically connects the third and ninth commandments" and E239 re Deu 5:20 using shav

Database Cross-References

cmd-evidence.db (642 items): - E203: Shav (H7723) definition -- emptiness, falsehood, worthlessness (Exo 20:7) - E239: Deu 5:20 uses shav instead of sheqer for 9th commandment - E237: Agur asks God to remove shav and lies (Pro 30:8) - E238: Psa 24:4 uses nasa with shav - E241: Israel declared God's service shav/vain (Mal 3:14) - E470: Lev 19:11 -- steal, deal falsely, lie linked - E479: Mal 3:5 -- swift witness against oppressors - E495: Mat 15:19 -- false witness proceeds from heart - E496: Mat 19:18 -- Jesus quotes ninth commandment - E497: Mrk 10:19 -- Jesus adds "Defraud not" - N036: Shav linguistically connects 3rd and 9th commandments

law-evidence.db: - E186: Deu 19:15 -- two or three witnesses required - E187: Deu 19:18-19 -- false witness penalty (lex talionis) - E204: Mat 18:16 -- Jesus applies two-witness rule - E205: 1Ti 5:19 -- Paul applies two-witness rule to elders

law-study.db: - law-29: "Ninth Commandment -- Thou shalt not bear false witness" analyzed re what continues/ceased

Focus Areas

  1. The shav/sheqer distinction -- Why does Exodus use sheqer (H8267) and Deuteronomy use shav (H7723)? What is the semantic range of each? Do they expand or narrow the commandment's scope? (cmd-04 already studied shav extensively)
  2. Courtroom vs. universal scope -- The specific language "bear witness against thy neighbour" (anah ed) suggests legal testimony, but the broader biblical usage (Lev 19:11; Pro 6:16-19; Col 3:9) extends to all lying. Trace the expansion.
  3. The Proverbs wisdom tradition -- Proverbs contains the densest concentration of truth/lie vocabulary. Analyze the cluster in Pro 6:16-19 (seven abominations), 12:17,19,22, 14:5,25, 19:5,9, 25:18.
  4. God's character as truth vs. Satan's character as liar -- Tit 1:2 / Heb 6:18 (God cannot lie) vs. Jhn 8:44 (devil is father of lies). Rev 21:8; 22:15 as eschatological consequences.
  5. Jesus's teaching on truthfulness -- Mat 5:33-37 (already partially analyzed in cmd-04). How does "let your yea be yea" relate to the ninth commandment?
  6. The Rahab/midwives cases -- Rahab (Jos 2; Heb 11:31; Jas 2:25) and Hebrew midwives (Exo 1:15-21) -- how does the Bible treat these cases of deception? Are they commended FOR lying or DESPITE lying?
  7. NT expansion -- Eph 4:25; Col 3:9 (put off lying); Act 5:1-10 (Ananias/Sapphira); 1Jn 2:4 (claiming to know God but not keeping commandments = liar)
  8. The false witness penalty -- Deu 19:15-21 (lex talionis for false witnesses); DEU 22:13-19 (false accusation of bride)
  9. Slander, gossip, and talebeating -- Lev 19:16; PSA 15:1,3; PRO 16:28; 26:20 as extensions of the false witness principle
  10. Cross-commandment connections -- How the 9th relates to the 3rd (shav link) and 8th (Lev 19:11 trilogy)

Research Instructions

You are the Research Agent. Execute this study by:

  1. Read the SKILL.md at C:/Users/Michael/.claude/skills/bible-study2/SKILL.md for full tool documentation and principles
  2. Read your agent instructions at C:/Users/Michael/.claude/skills/bible-study2/agents/research-agent.md
  3. Read the series methodology at D:/bible/bible-studies/cmd-series-methodology.md
  4. Follow the answer-question workflow from the skill
  5. Retrieve ALL verse text for the following references from kjv.txt (use Grep tool):
  6. Core: Exo 20:16; Deu 5:20
  7. Lev 19: Lev 19:11,12,16
  8. Evidence laws: Exo 23:1,7; Lev 5:1; Num 35:30; Deu 17:6-7; Deu 19:15-21; Deu 22:13-19
  9. Proverbs: Pro 6:16-19; 10:18; 12:17,19,22; 13:5; 14:5,25; 19:5,9; 21:6; 24:28; 25:18; 26:24-28
  10. Psalms: Psa 5:6,9; 12:2,3; 15:1-5; 24:3-5; 31:18; 34:13; 50:19,20; 52:2-5; 58:3; 101:5,7; 116:11; 119:29,163; 120:2-4; 144:8
  11. Prophets: Isa 59:3,4,12,13; Jer 7:8,28; 9:3,5,6,8; Hos 4:1,2; Mic 6:12; Nah 3:1; Zep 3:13; Zec 8:16,17
  12. Jesus: Mat 5:33-37; 12:36; 15:19; 19:18; 26:59-61; Jhn 8:44; 14:6
  13. NT: Act 5:1-10; Rom 1:25; Eph 4:25; Col 3:9; 1Ti 1:9,10; 4:2; Tit 1:2; Heb 6:18; 1Pe 2:1,22; 3:10; 1Jn 1:10; 2:4; Rev 14:5; 21:8,27; 22:15
  14. Case studies: Exo 1:15-21; Jos 2:1-6; Heb 11:31; Jas 2:25; 1Ki 21:7-13
  15. Run Hebrew parser on:
  16. Exo 20:16 (the commandment itself)
  17. Deu 5:20 (the Deuteronomic version with shav)
  18. Run Greek parser on:
  19. Mat 5:33-37 (Jesus on oaths)
  20. Col 3:9 (lie not one to another)
  21. Jhn 8:44 (father of lies)
  22. Run cross-testament parallels (BOTH --hybrid-ot AND --hybrid-nt) for:
  23. EXO 20:16
  24. DEU 5:20
  25. PRO 12:22
  26. JHN 8:44
  27. REV 21:8
  28. Run concept_context.py for EXO 20:16
  29. Query databases:
    • python D:/bible/evidence_db.py --db D:/bible/bible-studies/cmd-evidence.db search "false witness lie truth" (642 items)
    • python D:/bible/study_db.py --db D:/bible/bible-studies/cmd-study.db find-passage "Exo 20:16"
    • python D:/bible/study_db.py --db D:/bible/bible-studies/cmd-study.db find-word "shaqer"
    • python D:/bible/study_db.py --db D:/bible/bible-studies/cmd-study.db find-word "sheqer"
    • python D:/bible/evidence_db.py --db D:/bible/bible-studies/law-evidence.db search "false witness"
    • python D:/bible/study_db.py --db D:/bible/bible-studies/law-study.db search "false witness ninth commandment" --top 5
  30. Complete Strong's lookups (search_strongs.py) for:
    • H7723 (shav) -- --lookup and --lexicon
    • H8267 (sheqer) -- --lookup and --lexicon
    • H5707 (ed) -- --lookup and --lexicon
    • H6030 (anah) -- --lookup and --lexicon
    • H571 (emeth) -- --lookup and --lexicon
    • H3576 (kazab) -- --lookup and --lexicon
    • G5576 (pseudomartureo) -- --lookup and --lexicon
    • G5577 (pseudomarturia) -- --lookup and --lexicon
    • G5571 (pseudes) -- --lookup and --lexicon
    • G5579 (pseudos) -- --lookup and --lexicon
    • G225 (aletheia) -- --lookup and --lexicon
  31. Write research files to this folder:
    • 01-topics.md - Nave's topics and full entries
    • 02-verses.md - All verse texts retrieved with context
    • 04-word-studies.md - Strong's research
    • raw-data/ - Raw tool output organized by category
  32. Do NOT write 03-analysis.md or CONCLUSION.md -- those are for the analysis agent

Series context: This is study 10 of 13 in the Ten Commandments Deep Dive series. Previous studies have already analyzed: - cmd-04 (3rd Commandment): Extensive shav (H7723) analysis; Mat 5:33-37 on oaths; the shav connection between 3rd and 9th commandments - cmd-09 (8th Commandment): Lev 19:11 trilogy (steal, deal falsely, lie) - All prior commandment studies (cmd-01 through cmd-09) are indexed in cmd-study.db and cmd-evidence.db

Workflow

answer-question

Scoped: 2026-02-27 Folder: bible-studies/cmd-10-ninth-commandment-false-witness/