Skip to content

Bible Study: 8th Commandment — Do Not Steal (Exo 20:15)

Question

What does the Bible say about the eighth commandment? Trace it beyond physical theft to man-stealing/kidnapping (Exo 21:16; Deu 24:7; 1 Tim 1:10), defrauding workers (Lev 19:13; Jas 5:1-6), just weights and measures (Lev 19:35-36; Deu 25:13-15; Amo 8:5), and robbing God (Mal 3:8-10). What does the NT say — Paul (Eph 4:28), the rich young ruler (Mat 19:18), Zacchaeus's restitution (Luk 19:8), and the kingdom exclusion (1 Cor 6:10)? Examine: Exo 20:15, Exo 21:16, Lev 19:11,13,35-36, Deu 24:7; 25:13-15, Mal 3:8-10, Mat 19:18, Luk 19:8, Eph 4:28, 1 Cor 6:10, Jas 5:1-6, 1 Tim 1:10.

Series Context

Study 9 of 13 in the Ten Commandments Deep Dive series (cmd-XX). Follow the cmd-series-methodology.md at D:/bible/bible-studies/cmd-series-methodology.md.

INVESTIGATIVE METHODOLOGY: - You are an investigator, not an advocate. Your job is to report what the evidence says. - Gather evidence comprehensively. Trace the commandment from Genesis to Revelation. - Do NOT state opinions. State what the text says. - Do not use editorial characterizations like "genuine tension," "strongest argument," "most significant challenge," "honestly acknowledge," or "non-intuitive reading." Simply state what each passage says. - When presenting findings, state: "The text says X" (explicit). Then if needed: "From this, it follows that Y" (necessary implication) or "This has been interpreted to mean Z" (inference). - Never use language like "irrefutable," "obviously," or "clearly proves." Use "the text states," "this is consistent with." - The conclusion should emerge FROM the evidence, not be imposed ON it.

Discovered Scope

Topics Found (from naves_semantic.py)

Topic Score Key Verse References
THEFT AND THIEVES 0.66 EXO 20:15; 21:16; 22:1-4,10-15; LEV 6:2-7; 19:11,13; DEU 5:19; 23:24,25; PSA 50:18; 62:10; 119:61; PRO 6:30,31; 21:7; ISA 61:8; JER 2:26; 7:9,10; EZK 22:29; HOS 4:1,2; NAM 3:1; ZEC 5:3; MAT 6:19,20; 15:19; 19:18; 21:13; 27:38,44; MRK 7:21,22; 11:17; 15:27; LUK 18:20; 19:45,46; JHN 10:1; ROM 2:21; 13:9; 1CO 6:8,10; EPH 4:28; TIT 2:10; 1PE 4:15; REV 3:3; 9:21
STEALING 0.66 See THEFT
ROBBERY 0.57 LEV 19:13; ISA 61:8; EZK 18:10,13; 33:15; JDG 9:25; LUK 10:30
ROBBERS 0.50 PRO 1:11-16; JER 7:11; HOS 6:9; 7:1
KIDNAPPING 0.79 EXO 21:16; DEU 24:7; JDG 21:20-23
DISHONESTY 0.38 LEV 6:2-7; 19:13,35,36; DEU 25:13-16; JOB 24:2-11; PSA 37:21; 50:18; 62:10; PRO 3:27,28; 11:1; 20:10,14,17,23; ISA 32:7; JER 7:8-10; 9:4-6,8; 22:13; EZK 22:29; HOS 4:1,2; 12:7; AMO 3:10; 8:5; MIC 6:10,11; NAM 3:1; ZEP 1:9; ZEC 5:3,4; LUK 16:1-8; 1TH 4:6; JAS 5:4
EXTORTION 0.41 PSA 109:11; ISA 16:4; EZK 22:12; MIC 3:2,3; MAT 23:25; LUK 18:11; 1CO 5:10,11; 6:10
WEIGHTS 0.63 LEV 19:35,36; DEU 25:13-15; PRO 11:1; 16:11; 20:10,23; MIC 6:10,11
BALANCES 0.34 JOB 31:6; ISA 40:12,15; LEV 19:36; PRO 16:11; HOS 12:7; AMO 8:5; MIC 6:11; PRO 11:1; 20:23
WAGES 0.47 LEV 19:13; DEU 24:14,15; 25:4; JER 22:13; HAG 1:6; MAL 3:5; MAT 10:10; 20:1-15; LUK 3:14; 10:7; ROM 4:4; 6:23; COL 4:1; JAS 5:4
EMPLOYER 0.35 LEV 25:43; DEU 5:14; 24:14,15; LEV 19:13; JOB 31:13-15; PRO 22:16; 29:21; JER 22:13; MAL 3:5; MAT 10:10; 20:10-15; LUK 10:7; ROM 4:4; EPH 6:9; COL 4:1; 1TI 5:18; PHM 1:15,16; JAS 5:4,5
RESTITUTION n/a EXO 21:30-36; 22:1-4; LEV 6:2-5; 24:18; NUM 5:7; PRO 6:30,31; JOB 20:18; EZK 33:15; LUK 19:8
TITHES n/a GEN 14:20; 28:22; LEV 27:30-33; NUM 18:21-24; DEU 12:6,7; 14:22-29; 26:12-15; NEH 10:37,38; 13:10,12; MAL 3:8,10; MAT 23:23; LUK 11:42; 18:12; HEB 7:2-6

Verse References (from Nave's entries, consolidated)

A. The Commandment Itself: - EXO 20:15; DEU 5:19

B. Man-Stealing / Kidnapping (capital offense): - EXO 21:16; DEU 24:7; JDG 21:20-23; 1TI 1:10

C. Theft Case Law (restitution, property): - EXO 22:1-4,10-15; LEV 6:2-7; NUM 5:7

D. Prohibition of Stealing, Lying, Deception: - LEV 19:11,13

E. Just Weights and Measures: - LEV 19:35,36; DEU 25:13-16; PRO 11:1; 16:11; 20:10,23; HOS 12:7; AMO 8:5; MIC 6:10,11

F. Defrauding Workers / Withholding Wages: - LEV 19:13; DEU 24:14,15; JER 22:13; MAL 3:5; JAS 5:4,5; COL 4:1

G. Robbery Condemned: - LEV 19:13; ISA 61:8; EZK 18:10,13; 22:29; 33:15

H. Extortion Condemned: - PSA 109:11; EZK 22:12; MIC 3:2,3; MAT 23:25; 1CO 5:10,11; 6:10

I. Robbing God (tithes/offerings): - MAL 3:8-10; NEH 13:10,12

J. Restitution Principle: - EXO 22:1-4; LEV 6:2-5; NUM 5:7; PRO 6:30,31; EZK 33:15; LUK 19:8

K. Prophetic Denunciation of Theft/Dishonesty: - JER 2:26; 7:9,10; EZK 22:29; HOS 4:1,2; NAM 3:1; ZEC 5:3,4; ZEP 1:9; AMO 3:10

L. Wisdom Literature on Theft: - PSA 50:18; 62:10; 119:61; PRO 6:30,31; 21:7; JOB 24:2-11

M. NT Treatment — Jesus: - MAT 6:19,20; 15:19; 19:18; 21:13; MRK 7:21,22; 10:19; 11:17; LUK 18:20; 19:8 (Zacchaeus); 19:45,46; JHN 10:1,10

N. NT Treatment — Paul and Epistles: - ROM 2:21; 13:9; 1CO 6:8,10; EPH 4:28; TIT 2:10; 1TH 4:6; 1TI 1:10

O. NT Treatment — General: - 1PE 4:15; REV 3:3; 9:21

P. Instances of Theft in Scripture: - Rachel stealing household gods: GEN 31:19,34,35 - Achan: JOS 7:11 - Micah: JDG 17:2 - Spies of Laish: JDG 18:14-27 - Judas: JHN 12:6

Strong's Numbers Found (from semantic_strongs.py)

Hebrew — Theft/Stealing: | Strong's | Word | Transliteration | Definition | Relevance | |----------|------|-----------------|------------|-----------| | H1589 | גָּנַב | ganab | to thieve; to deceive; carry away, steal | Core verb in 8th commandment (Exo 20:15) | | H1590 | גַּנָּב | gannab | a stealer; thief | Noun form of ganab | | H1591 | גְּנֵבָה | genebah | stealing; something stolen; theft | Abstract noun from ganab |

Hebrew — Robbery/Plunder: | Strong's | Word | Transliteration | Definition | Relevance | |----------|------|-----------------|------------|-----------| | H1497 | גָּזַל | gazal | to pluck off; rob, spoil, take by force | Robbery — distinct from ganab (stealth) | | H1498 | גָּזֵל | gazel | robbery; thing taken by violence | Noun form | | H6906 | קָבַע | qaba | to cover; defraud, rob, spoil | Used in Mal 3:8 — "Will a man rob God?" |

Hebrew — Oppression/Fraud: | Strong's | Word | Transliteration | Definition | Relevance | |----------|------|-----------------|------------|-----------| | H6231 | עָשַׁק | ashaq | to press upon, oppress, defraud | Used in Lev 19:13, Deu 24:14, Mal 3:5 | | H6233 | עֹשֶׁק | osheq | injury, fraud, oppression, extortion | Abstract noun — economic injustice | | H8496 | תֹּךְ | tok | oppression, fraud, deceit | Psa 72:14; 10:7 |

Hebrew — Wages/Hire: | Strong's | Word | Transliteration | Definition | Relevance | |----------|------|-----------------|------------|-----------| | H7936 | שָׂכַר | sakar | to hire | Wage contexts | | H7916 | שָׂכִיר | sakir | a man at wages; hired servant, hireling | Worker in Lev 19:13; Deu 24:14 | | H4909 | מַשְׂכֹּרֶת | maskoreth | wages, reward | Wage payment |

Greek — Theft/Stealing: | Strong's | Word | Transliteration | Definition | Relevance | |----------|------|-----------------|------------|-----------| | G2813 | κλέπτω | klepto | to filch; steal | Core Greek verb for stealing (Eph 4:28; Mat 19:18) | | G2812 | κλέπτης | kleptes | a stealer; thief | Used in 1 Cor 6:10; Jhn 10:1; 12:6 | | G2829 | κλοπή | klope | stealing; theft | Abstract noun (Mat 15:19; Mrk 7:22) | | G2809 | κλέμμα | klemma | stealing; the thing stolen | Rev 9:21 |

Greek — Man-Stealing: | Strong's | Word | Transliteration | Definition | Relevance | |----------|------|-----------------|------------|-----------| | G405 | ἀνδραποδιστής | andrapodistes | an enslaver; man-stealer | 1 Tim 1:10 — slave traders condemned |

Greek — Defrauding: | Strong's | Word | Transliteration | Definition | Relevance | |----------|------|-----------------|------------|-----------| | G650 | ἀποστερέω | apostereo | to despoil; defraud, deprive | Mrk 10:19; 1 Cor 6:7-8; Jas 5:4 |

Study Question Relevance
cmd-07-sixth-commandment-do-not-murder 6th Commandment — Do Not Murder (Exo 20:13) Prior commandment in series; shares cross-refs (Jer 7:9, Hos 4:2, Rom 13:9) where theft is listed alongside murder
cmd-08-seventh-commandment-adultery 7th Commandment — Do Not Commit Adultery (Exo 20:14) Adjacent commandment; shares pattern of Jesus deepening the law; Rom 13:9 lists all together
slavery-in-bible Slavery in the Bible: Israel's Laws Directly relevant — covers kidnapping ban (Exo 21:16), andrapodistes (1 Tim 1:10), runaway slave protection (Deu 23:15-16)
law-05-civil-judicial-laws Civil/Judicial Laws Contains word studies on G2813 (klepto), G2809 (klemma), H1498 (gazel); analysis of Exo 22:1-15 property/theft laws
law-29-what-continues-what-ceased What Continues, What Ceased Analyzes the 8th commandment's NT continuity

Key findings from related studies: - cmd-07 (Murder): Established the pattern of tracing a commandment from the Decalogue text through OT case law, prophetic expansion, and NT deepening. The 6th commandment study showed Jesus expanding from external act to internal attitude (anger = murder). The same pattern applies here. - cmd-08 (Adultery): Established Rom 13:9 as a key verse listing multiple commandments together, including "Thou shalt not steal." Paul groups all under "love thy neighbour as thyself." The seventh commandment study found that the law's unity means breaking one breaks all (Jas 2:10-11). - slavery-in-bible: Directly covers man-stealing (Exo 21:16) as a capital offense under the 8th commandment's extension. The study found G405 (andrapodistes, "man-stealer/slave-trader") in 1 Tim 1:10 listed among the lawless. The kidnapping ban (death penalty) and runaway slave law (Deu 23:15-16) together structurally undermine chattel slavery. - law-05: Contains detailed word studies on theft vocabulary (klepto, klemma, gazel) and analysis of Exo 22:1-15 property and theft laws (restitution: 4x/5x for livestock, 2x for general property). - law-29: Confirms the 8th commandment continues in force in the NT: "Let him that stole steal no more" (Eph 4:28), "nor thieves...shall inherit the kingdom" (1 Cor 6:10), Mat 19:18.

Focus Areas

(Derived from tool discoveries)

  1. The commandment verb ganab (H1589) — Analyze morphology and semantic range. Ganab implies stealth/secrecy (as opposed to gazal, H1497, which is open robbery/plunder). How does this distinction matter for the commandment's scope?

  2. Man-stealing as capital theft (Exo 21:16; Deu 24:7) — The Nave's KIDNAPPING entry shows this as a death-penalty offense under the 8th commandment umbrella. 1 Tim 1:10 uses andrapodistes (G405), a NT hapax legomenon. The slavery study already established the connection — verify and integrate.

  3. Defrauding workers (Lev 19:13; Deu 24:14-15; Mal 3:5; Jas 5:4) — Nave's WAGES and EMPLOYER entries reveal extensive OT regulation. H6231 (ashaq, oppress/defraud) appears in Lev 19:13 alongside the 8th commandment context. G650 (apostereo) connects Mrk 10:19 (Jesus adds "defraud not" to the commandment list), 1 Cor 6:7-8, and Jas 5:4.

  4. Just weights and measures (Lev 19:35-36; Deu 25:13-15; Pro 11:1; Amo 8:5) — Nave's WEIGHTS and BALANCES entries show this as a form of theft by deception. The prophets (Hosea, Amos, Micah) specifically denounce false balances as covenant violation.

  5. Robbing God (Mal 3:8-10) — H6906 (qaba) is used uniquely in Malachi — "Will a man rob God?" Nave's TITHES entry cross-references this. The verb qaba means "to cover/defraud."

  6. Restitution principle (Exo 22:1-4; Lev 6:2-5; Luk 19:8) — Nave's RESTITUTION entry links OT law to Zacchaeus. The law required 2x-5x restitution; Zacchaeus voluntarily offers 4x. EZK 33:15 — restoring the pledge is a condition for life.

  7. NT deepening and transformation (Eph 4:28) — Paul does not merely prohibit stealing; he commands the positive opposite: work and give. This mirrors the 6th commandment pattern (don't murder → love). Kingdom exclusion: thieves, extortioners will not inherit (1 Cor 6:10).

  8. Prophetic lists combining commandments — Jer 7:9-10 and Hos 4:2 list theft alongside murder, adultery, false oaths (Decalogue violations together). This pattern was already documented in cmd-07 and cmd-08.

  9. Jesus and theft — The rich young ruler encounter (Mat 19:18); Zacchaeus (Luk 19:8); temple cleansing as "den of thieves" (Mat 21:13); the thief on the cross (Luk 23:39-43); Jesus as door vs. thief/robber (Jhn 10:1-10).

  10. Cross-commandment connections — Stealing intersects with the 9th commandment (dishonesty, false dealing — Lev 19:11 links "steal" and "deal falsely" and "lie"), the 10th commandment (coveting precedes stealing — Jos 7:21 Achan), and the 5th commandment (Pro 28:24 "whoso robbeth his father or mother").

Research Instructions

You are the Research Agent. Execute this study by:

  1. Read the SKILL.md at C:/Users/Michael/.claude/skills/bible-study2/SKILL.md (Windows) for full tool documentation and principles
  2. Read your agent instructions at C:/Users/Michael/.claude/skills/bible-study2/agents/research-agent.md (Windows)
  3. Read the series methodology at D:/bible/bible-studies/cmd-series-methodology.md
  4. Follow the answer-question workflow from the skill
  5. Retrieve ALL verse text for key passages from D:/bible/tools/data/kjv.txt:
  6. Commandment text: Exo 20:15; Deu 5:19
  7. Man-stealing/kidnapping: Exo 21:16; Deu 24:7; Jdg 21:20-23
  8. Theft case law / restitution: Exo 22:1-4,10-15; Lev 6:2-7; Num 5:7
  9. Prohibition cluster: Lev 19:11,13,35-36
  10. Just weights: Deu 25:13-16; Pro 11:1; 16:11; 20:10,23; Amo 8:5; Mic 6:10-11; Hos 12:7
  11. Defrauding workers: Deu 24:14-15; Jer 22:13; Mal 3:5; Jas 5:1-6; Col 4:1
  12. Robbing God: Mal 3:8-10; Neh 13:10-12
  13. Robbery condemned: Isa 61:8; Ezk 18:10-13; 22:29; 33:15
  14. Prophetic denunciations: Jer 2:26; 7:9-10; Hos 4:1-2; Zec 5:3-4; Zep 1:9
  15. Wisdom/Psalms: Psa 50:18; 62:10; 119:61; Pro 6:30-31; 21:7; 28:24; 30:9; Job 24:2-11
  16. Jesus & theft: Mat 6:19-20; 15:19; 19:18; 21:13; Mrk 7:21-22; 10:19; Luk 18:20; 19:1-10 (Zacchaeus full context); Jhn 10:1,8,10; 12:6
  17. Paul & epistles: Rom 2:21; 13:9; 1 Cor 6:8-10; Eph 4:28; 1 Th 4:6; 1 Tim 1:9-10; Tit 2:10
  18. General NT: 1 Pet 4:15; Rev 3:3; 9:21
  19. OT instances: Gen 31:19,34-35 (Rachel); Jos 7:11,20-21 (Achan); Jdg 17:2; 18:14-27
  20. Run Hebrew parser on:
  21. Exo 20:15 (the commandment itself — lo tignob)
  22. Lev 19:11 (the trio: steal, deal falsely, lie)
  23. Run Greek parser on:
  24. Eph 4:28 (steal no more; rather let him labour)
  25. 1 Cor 6:10 (nor thieves...shall inherit)
  26. 1 Tim 1:10 (andrapodistes — man-stealer)
  27. Run cross-testament parallels for:
  28. Exo 20:15 (both --hybrid-ot and --hybrid-nt)
  29. Mal 3:8 (both directions)
  30. Eph 4:28 (both directions)
  31. Lev 19:13 (both directions)
  32. Run concept_context.py for Exo 20:15
  33. Query databases:
    • python D:/bible/evidence_db.py --db D:/bible/bible-studies/cmd-evidence.db search "steal theft rob" (569 items)
    • python D:/bible/study_db.py --db D:/bible/bible-studies/cmd-study.db search "stealing theft eighth commandment" --top 5
    • python D:/bible/study_db.py --db D:/bible/bible-studies/law-study.db search "stealing theft rob" --top 5
    • python D:/bible/evidence_db.py --db D:/bible/bible-studies/law-evidence.db search "thou shalt not steal"
  34. Complete Strong's lookups (search_strongs.py --lookup and --lexicon) for:
  35. Write research files to this folder:
    • 01-topics.md — Nave's topics and full entries
    • 02-verses.md — All verse texts retrieved with context
    • 04-word-studies.md — Strong's research
    • raw-data/ — Raw tool output organized by category
  36. Do NOT write 03-analysis.md or CONCLUSION.md — those are for the analysis agent

Workflow

answer-question

Scoped: 2026-02-27 Folder: bible-studies/cmd-09-eighth-commandment-stealing/